MISUNDERSTOOD DEFENDER
In Baggage burdens. defender
of the guilty could be ascribed to Alice Rezley.
Jill could not
understand how Alice, her mother, could shield her
father, Frank Rezley, from criticism for his violent behavior. Josey,
Alice’s mother, could believe that Alice would put up with Frank’s drinking.
Frank couldn’t believe that Alice would stand up for
their disobedient daughters.
In preserving peace in her
home Alice, by protecting Frank, ended up alienating herself from her mother. What
weakness did Alice see in Frank that motivated her to choose to continue to support
him? The only weakness that Josey could see is that’s Frank
succumbed to the temptation of alcohol. That warranted no shielding.
“Why don’t you leave him?” was the frustrated
plea of Jill after having witnessed that her father once again broke his
promise not to drink. The psychological damage that Frank was doing to Jill
would have been an acceptable reason for Alice to kick Frank out of the house. Could
the potential trials of a single mother in the 1970's explain why Alice remained
with her marital partner?
“How can you protect those kids?” Frank
couldn’t believe that his wife would cover for his daughters who frequently
didn’t pick up after themselves, were mouthy or wanted to spend money
extravagantly. Why did Frank always have to be the disciplinarian? His father
wouldn’t put up with it, and Frank wouldn’t either.
Could love for her husband explain why Alice called for respect from her
children for their father? Jill would question how she could love such a
sinner. Josey would wonder what
kind of love could continually forgive such a faulty man.
Love undisciplined
kids? That would be hard for Frank to grasp.
In the end
Kathy, Jill’s sister, discovers and understands her mother’s actions. While
Kathy’s explanation helps end Jill’s ambivalent feelings toward her mother, Jill
isn’t completely ready to see her father in a new light.
How
can one love or forgive a self-centered, hurtful person? Who can do it?
Do
you know of one who loved or forgave a despicable person?
The
character, Julie,
in Baggage burdens fulfills two
critical roles in the novel––a vital connection to Jill’s past and a supportive
companion for Jill. The difficulty
of her roles is explored in my next blog.